By Antony. When in doubt, begin where you began. I set out to familiarize myself with Glen Hansard’s work with The Frames and The Swell Season because I fell in love with his 2012 solo album Rhythm And Repose. Of course that was about two years ago, and I did nothing. The catalyst for finally doing it was that I saw Glen Hansard at the Hollywood Bowl a few weeks ago. He and his large band—about a dozen people—were fantastic. He overflowed with joy and gratitude, and his storytelling was absolutely charming. In fact, my only complaint was that some backstage miscommunication truncated Hansard’s set—though with a flash of Irish rebellion, he played nearly 30 minutes past curfew.
So in the afterglow of the show, I found the motivation to give some time to one of the finest folk musicians working today. What follows is what I’ve learned. Fair warning: I’m sure my list is heretical to any longtime Hansard follower and that doesn’t bother me one bit.
Taking a queue from one of my favorite features on Stereogum, I’m going to list the albums from worst to best (waste a little time later with their lists for U2, Bruce Springsteen, and Ryan Adams). A technical note: The Frames’ first album, Another Love Song, was not available to me, and I excluded their live records Breadcrumb Trail and Set List from this list.
- The Swell Season, The Swell Season (2007)
The Swell Season
is Glen Hansard’s first collaboration with Markéta Irglová, a Czech singer. The two would go on to star in the film Once
together (see below), and several of the songs on this album are re-recorded for the soundtrack, while two appear on The Frames’ album The Cost
. And really, this is the problem with the album. Everything here works; it’s a very easy listen, often beautiful, but most of its strongest moments are trumped by versions of those songs on other releases. The exception is “Leave”
—the version here is clearly superior to the Once
version. “Drown Out”
is also a highlight.
- The Frames, Fitzcarraldo (1996)
The Frames’ second album sounds a lot like late 90s alternative rock with an Irish twist. I hear hints of Pearl Jam and The Foo Fighters in the music, but the heart remains passionate, Irish folk music. Perhaps because of this 90s sound, I suspect this album would’ve been my favorite if I’d heard it when it originally came out, but having only listened to it in the last few weeks, I find it uneven—there’s so much about the 90s I don’t care about anymore. No matter the production, a good song shines and Fitzcarraldo
has several. But the two best really become what they are as they evolved live. The title track has gotten even more epic, and “Say It To Me Now”
opens many of Hansard’s shows. He plays it acoustically, without amps (there’s a similar version on Once
). It’s rousing and timeless.
- The Swell Season, Strict Joy (2009)
I understand why this album sounds like it does. The production is a little slicker than The Swell Season
, and the songs feel a little more thought-out. Nothing wrong with this really, but the songs here lack some of the spontaneity of the chemistry between Hansard and Irglová that made Once
so compelling. I read a summary of this album somewhere on the internet that called it a “more mature” effort. Does that mean boring? Well, whatever it means, there are some really elegant songs worth not missing—“Low Rising,” “In These Arms,”
and Irglová’s “I Have Loved You Wrong.”
You should pick up the Deluxe Edition of Strict Joy because it includes a live performance in Milwaukee in 2008 that captures pretty much everything I loved about Glen Hansard live. His cover of The Pixies’ “Gigantic” here is awesome. His explanation of “Drown Out” gives me chills.
- The Frames, Dance The Devil… (1999)
The Frames’ third album is another uneven outing, but I like most of it more each time I listen. I think there’s two ways to hear it: It’s either an improved Fitzcarraldo
or a desert wandering before finding their voice on For The Birds
. “Pavement Tune”
is probably the best Fitzcarraldo
song not on Fitzcarraldo
. But songs like “Star Star”
and “God Bless Mom”
suggest a band beginning to stretch themselves. They still sound like 90s alternative rock, but the sound is a little less cluttered and the songwriting a little stronger, a little more epic. You can start to see where the U2 comparisons come from (you know besides the Irish thing), but they’ve always sounded a little earthier than their compatriots.
- Glen Hansard & Markéta Irglová, Once (2007)
As with all movies that revolve around musicians, this is more than just a soundtrack because so much of the plot conflict is worked out through
the music. So the more you like this movie, the higher this soundtrack climbs in your estimation. I watched it when it came out, long before my Glen Hansard conversion. I liked it a lot back then and would probably like it even more now. But, disentangling the movie from the music, I think this soundtrack works as an album. It retains the rough charm of the busker on a street corner (something Hansard did since he was 13) while the songs show the insight of seasoned songwriter.
Can we talk about “Falling Slowly”? In the Milwaukee performance from the Strict Joy Deluxe Edition, Hansard attempts to describe the way that this song has transcended everything he could have imagined for it. I’m certain that’s true. It’s the type of song you probably have to wonder if you really wrote—perhaps the universe delivered it to you in a dream or something—it’s that perfect.
- The Frames, Burn The Maps (2005)
This is probably really a tie with Once
. That’s fitting since this represents the opposite end of Hansard’s music. Whereas Once
is the most readily accessible album, Burn The Maps
is the murkiest and moodiest one. This is the only Frames I’d heard in the distant past. I had a copy of this album when it came out in 2005, and I have a distinct memory of driving the empty San Francisco Bay Area freeways at 5 AM. The drive was ghostly. I associate Bay Area roads with crowds—crowded in the way that makes you instinctually pull your shoulders in because all the cars are that
close to you. The otherworldly quality Burn The Maps
had for me that morning turns out to be more than my strange experience; it inhabits the music. You can hear it in “Happy,” “Dream Awake,”
To me though, the highlight of this predawn album is the closer, “Locusts.”
A moment of sad, well-earned clarity, driven by a gorgeous piano line.
- The Frames, The Cost (2007)
If not for The Swell Season
competing for my affection, this album might have taken first place. The renditions of “Falling Slowly”
and “When Your Mind’s Made Up”
here are expansive; the addition of a little noise changes the songs in really interesting ways. But are they my favorite versions? I don’t know—depends on my mood, I think. The Cost
is nearly a pop record compared to Burn The Maps
. The songs are sharp, and the band breathes together. While I rank The Cost
only at #3, this is the Frames album I’d recommend to people who wanted to start somewhere.
- The Frames, For The Birds (2001)
This is my favorite Frames album. I know this because I started building a playlist for a Glen Hansard 101
Mix (see below), and by the end of my second listen, there were seven songs from For The Birds
. The sound successfully combines the strengths of Fitzcarraldo
and Dance The Devil
, creating a noisy folk-rock record with a lot of heart and charm. This is what I’ll be playing in that slow part of the afternoon when I need a little help making it to the evening. “Lay Me Down”
may be Glen Hansard’s first perfect song.
- Glen Hansard, Rhythm And Repose (2012)
Unsurprisingly, nothing knocked my first love out of the top spot. There are two possible reasons for this: (1) Objectively speaking, it’s actually the best thing Glen Hansard has ever done or (2) love is a strange thing. What can I say? Listen to it with an open heart, hoping for love—and perhaps I won’t have to explain.
The album title is a good way to begin. He said it’s something of a life philosophy—the two elements of a life, the rhythm of work and purpose and the repose that gives you the time to make sense of it all. Musically, rhythm is more central here than in Hansard’s previous work. A lot happens between the rhythm section and Hansard’s voice. Maybe this is what you’d call “urban folk”? Something about several of the songs (“Maybe Not Tonight,” “Love Don’t Leave Me Waiting”) reminds me of solo John Lennon. I don’t know why, but perhaps there’s a clue in that?
Okay, so it’s love—I can’t make the objective argument. The lyrics to “High Hope” wreck me. Hansard reaches into the deep well of humanity and finds something achingly beautiful: “Maybe when we’re both old and wise / Maybe when our hearts have had some time / I’m going to see you there / There—we can be natural / There—after all we’ve seen, we can do anything / There—where your heart is strong / Where we can go on and on / There—where the good times gone / Where we are forever young /Where your heart is strong / Where we can go on and on / There—I’m going to see you there.”
The Rest Of Glen Hansard
Now, an artist with such a long history has a rather long list of songs for soundtracks, compilations for charity, and B-sides. I can say that I’ve like most of the loose tracks I’ve come across. Several of these are represented on the Glen Hansard 101 mix below because as a folk musician one of the most important elements of his craft is reinterpreting the songs of our past. The Swell Season version of Dylan’s “You Ain’t Goin’ Nowhere” is joyful (and it was the exit music from my wedding ceremony). His take on Justin Timberlake’s “Cry Me A River” reminds you of the craft in Timberlake’s best work.
The Song Mix: Glen Hansard 101
For Glen Hansard 101 I had to pick an audience. You can’t make a mix without a listener in mind. Sometimes they are personal—only for you. Other times, you want to communicate something, build bridges, and that sort of thing. When I want to do that, I often think about my wife. Her taste is a lot like mine with some of the rougher edges sanded off. So the guiding principle for this was: While representing each album, who is the Glen Hansard she’d appreciate the most? This is my attempt at that (she’ll tell me if I got it wrong). Hope you enjoy it too.
Download here: S&N Mix 5: Glen Hansard 101
- Revelate (Frames, Fitzcarraldo)
- Star Star (Frames, Dance The Devil)
- God Bless Mom (Frames, Dance The Devil)
- Lay Me Down (Frames, For The Birds)
- Fighting On The Stairs (Frames, For The Birds)
- Fitzcarraldo (Live 2003) (Frames, The Roads Outgrown EP)
- Locusts (Frames, Burn The Maps)
- Happy (Frames, Burn The Maps)
- Leave (The Swell Season, S/T)
- When Your Mind’s Made Up (Frames, The Cost)
- Sad Songs (Frames, The Cost)
- Falling Slowly (Glen Hansard and Markéta Irglová, Once)
- Say It To Me Now (Glen Hansard and Markéta Irglová, Once)
- You Ain’t Goin’ Nowhere (Glen Hansard and Markéta Irglová, I’m Not There Sndtrk)
- Low Rising (The Swell Season, Strict Joy)
- Cry Me A River (Glen Hansard)
- High Hope (Glen Hansard, Rhythm And Repose)
- Love Don’t Leave Me Waiting (Glen Hansard, Rhythm And Repose)
- Step Out Of The Shadows (Glen Hansard, Drive All Night EP)